docs: sync ECC Tools judge execution (#1901)

docs/ECC-2.0-GA-ROADMAP.md

@@ -183,6 +183,12 @@ As of 2026-05-13:
   contract and fails closed unless hosted retrieval evidence, entitlement,
   remaining budget, and provider configuration are present. It still does not
   make live model calls.
+- ECC-Tools PR #72 merged as `973bc51e5436dd279ae5a890cce9811485eef0b5`
+  and executes the hosted promotion model judge behind explicit gates:
+  `PR_HOSTED_PROMOTION_MODEL_JUDGE_MODE=execute` now calls the configured
+  provider only after hosted retrieval evidence, entitlement, budget, provider,
+  and executor gates pass; the check remains non-blocking, strict-JSON-only,
+  and rejects uncited or non-hosted model output without echoing raw responses.
 - Handoff `ecc-supply-chain-audit-20260513-0645.md` under
   `~/.cluster-swarm/handoffs/`
   records the May 13 supply-chain sweep: no active lockfile/manifest hit for
@@ -479,10 +485,10 @@ is not complete unless the evidence column exists and has been freshly verified.
 | Claude and Codex plugin publication | Contact/submission path with required artifacts and status | Publication readiness, naming matrix, and May 12 dry-run evidence document plugin validation, clean-checkout Claude tag/install smoke, and Codex marketplace CLI shape | Needs explicit approval for real tag/push and marketplace submission |
 | Articles, tweets, and announcements | X thread, LinkedIn copy, GitHub release copy, push checklist | Draft launch collateral exists under rc.1 release docs | Needs URL-backed refresh |
 | AgentShield enterprise iteration | Policy gates, SARIF, packs, provenance, corpus, HTML reports, exception lifecycle audit, baseline drift Action/CLI surfaces, evidence-pack redaction, harness adapter registry, enterprise research roadmap, supply-chain hardened release path, CI-safe baseline fingerprints, corpus accuracy recommendations, remediation workflow phases, env proxy hijack corpus coverage | PRs #53, #55-#64, #67-#69, and #78-#82 landed with test evidence; native PDF export deferred in favor of self-contained HTML plus print-to-PDF until explicit enterprise demand appears; `docs/architecture/agentshield-enterprise-research-roadmap.md` now has baseline drift, evidence-pack bundle, redaction, adapter-registry, supply-chain hardening, hashed baseline fingerprints, corpus accuracy recommendation, remediation workflow, and env proxy hijack corpus slices landed | Next hosted evidence-pack workflow depth |
-| ECC Tools next-level app | Billing audit, PR checks, deep analyzer, sync backlog, evaluator/RAG corpus, analysis-depth readiness, hosted execution planning, hosted CI diagnostics, hosted security evidence review, hosted harness compatibility audit, hosted reference-set evaluation, hosted AI routing/cost review, hosted team backlog routing, hosted depth-plan check-run, PR-comment hosted job dispatch, hosted job result history/check-runs, hosted result status command, status-aware depth-plan recommendations, hosted promotion readiness, hosted promotion output scoring, hosted promotion retrieval planning, hosted promotion judge contract | PRs #26-#43 plus #53-#71 landed with test evidence, including AgentShield evidence-pack gap routing, canonical bundle recognition, supply-chain signature gates, PR draft follow-up Linear tracking, evidence-backed/deep-ready repository classification, the `/api/analysis/depth-plan` hosted job plan, `/api/analysis/jobs/ci-diagnostics`, `/api/analysis/jobs/security-evidence-review`, `/api/analysis/jobs/harness-compatibility-audit`, `/api/analysis/jobs/reference-set-evaluation`, `/api/analysis/jobs/ai-routing-cost-review`, `/api/analysis/jobs/team-backlog-routing`, the `ECC Tools / Hosted Depth Plan` check-run, `/ecc-tools analyze --job ...` PR-comment dispatch, non-blocking per-hosted-job result check-runs backed by 30-day result cache records, `/ecc-tools analyze --job status` cache lookup, cache-aware next-job recommendations in the depth-plan check-run, the `ECC Tools / Hosted Promotion Readiness` corpus-backed PR check-run, deterministic hosted-output scoring against cached completed job artifacts/findings, ranked retrieval/model-prompt planning, and the fail-closed `hosted-promotion-judge.v1` request contract for the next hosted promotion pass | Next work is live hosted model-judge execution behind the fixture gate |
+| ECC Tools next-level app | Billing audit, PR checks, deep analyzer, sync backlog, evaluator/RAG corpus, analysis-depth readiness, hosted execution planning, hosted CI diagnostics, hosted security evidence review, hosted harness compatibility audit, hosted reference-set evaluation, hosted AI routing/cost review, hosted team backlog routing, hosted depth-plan check-run, PR-comment hosted job dispatch, hosted job result history/check-runs, hosted result status command, status-aware depth-plan recommendations, hosted promotion readiness, hosted promotion output scoring, hosted promotion retrieval planning, hosted promotion judge contract, gated hosted promotion judge execution | PRs #26-#43 plus #53-#72 landed with test evidence, including AgentShield evidence-pack gap routing, canonical bundle recognition, supply-chain signature gates, PR draft follow-up Linear tracking, evidence-backed/deep-ready repository classification, the `/api/analysis/depth-plan` hosted job plan, `/api/analysis/jobs/ci-diagnostics`, `/api/analysis/jobs/security-evidence-review`, `/api/analysis/jobs/harness-compatibility-audit`, `/api/analysis/jobs/reference-set-evaluation`, `/api/analysis/jobs/ai-routing-cost-review`, `/api/analysis/jobs/team-backlog-routing`, the `ECC Tools / Hosted Depth Plan` check-run, `/ecc-tools analyze --job ...` PR-comment dispatch, non-blocking per-hosted-job result check-runs backed by 30-day result cache records, `/ecc-tools analyze --job status` cache lookup, cache-aware next-job recommendations in the depth-plan check-run, the `ECC Tools / Hosted Promotion Readiness` corpus-backed PR check-run, deterministic hosted-output scoring against cached completed job artifacts/findings, ranked retrieval/model-prompt planning, the fail-closed `hosted-promotion-judge.v1` request contract, and opt-in live model-judge execution behind hosted evidence, entitlement, budget, provider, executor, strict JSON, and citation gates | Next work is hosted promotion telemetry and operator review UX |
 | GitGuardian/Dependabot/CodeRabbit-style checks | Non-blocking taxonomy, deterministic follow-up checks, and local supply-chain gates | ECC-Tools risk taxonomy check plus follow-up signals landed, including Skill Quality, Deep Analyzer Evidence, Analyzer Corpus Evidence, RAG/Evaluator Evidence, PR Review/Salvage Evidence, and AgentShield evidence-pack evidence; #1846 added npm registry signature gates; #1848 added the supply-chain incident-response playbook and `pull_request_target` cache-poisoning validator guard; #1851 added the privileged checkout credential-persistence guard; AgentShield #78, JARVIS #13, and ECC-Tools #53 applied the same hardening outside trunk | Current supply-chain gate complete; deeper hosted review features remain future |
-| Harness-agnostic learning system | Audit, adapter matrix, observability, traces, promotion loop | Audit/adapters/observability gates plus `docs/architecture/evaluator-rag-prototype.md`, `examples/evaluator-rag-prototype/`, and ECC-Tools PR #40 define read-only stale-salvage, billing-readiness, CI-failure-diagnosis, harness-config-quality, AgentShield policy-exception, skill-quality evidence, deep-analyzer evidence, and RAG/evaluator comparison scenarios with trace, report, playbook, verifier, and predictive-check artifacts; ECC-Tools PRs #68-#71 now turn that corpus into a deterministic PR check-run gate with cached hosted-output scoring, ranked retrieval candidates, a model prompt seed, and a fail-closed hosted model-judge request contract | Deterministic hosted PR check, cached output scoring, retrieval planning, and judge contract integrated; live hosted model execution remains future |
+| Harness-agnostic learning system | Audit, adapter matrix, observability, traces, promotion loop | Audit/adapters/observability gates plus `docs/architecture/evaluator-rag-prototype.md`, `examples/evaluator-rag-prototype/`, and ECC-Tools PR #40 define read-only stale-salvage, billing-readiness, CI-failure-diagnosis, harness-config-quality, AgentShield policy-exception, skill-quality evidence, deep-analyzer evidence, and RAG/evaluator comparison scenarios with trace, report, playbook, verifier, and predictive-check artifacts; ECC-Tools PRs #68-#72 now turn that corpus into a deterministic PR check-run gate with cached hosted-output scoring, ranked retrieval candidates, a model prompt seed, a fail-closed hosted model-judge request contract, and opt-in live model execution behind strict hosted-evidence gates | Deterministic hosted PR check, cached output scoring, retrieval planning, judge contract, and gated model execution integrated |
-| Linear roadmap is detailed | Linear project status plus repo mirror | Repo mirror exists; issue creation was retried on 2026-05-12 and remains blocked by the workspace free issue limit; this May 13 sync adds ECC #1860, AgentShield #78-#82, JARVIS #13, ECC-Tools #53-#71, resolved queue/discussion counts, and notes that Linear connector status updates after ECC-Tools #68 remain blocked by a connector secret-owner error | Needs recurring status updates after connector recovery |
+| Linear roadmap is detailed | Linear project status plus repo mirror | Repo mirror exists; issue creation was retried on 2026-05-12 and remains blocked by the workspace free issue limit; this May 13 sync adds ECC #1860, AgentShield #78-#82, JARVIS #13, ECC-Tools #53-#72, resolved queue/discussion counts, and notes that Linear connector status updates after ECC-Tools #68 remain blocked by a connector secret-owner error | Needs recurring status updates after connector recovery |
 | Flow separation and progress tracking | Flow lanes with owner artifacts and update cadence | This roadmap defines lanes below and `docs/architecture/progress-sync-contract.md` makes GitHub/Linear/handoff/roadmap sync part of the readiness gate | Active |
 | Realtime Linear sync | Project updates while issue limit is blocked; issues later | ECC-Tools #39 implements opt-in Linear API sync for deferred follow-up backlog items, and ECC-Tools #54 adds copy-ready PR drafts to that backlog when draft PR shells are not opened; `docs/architecture/progress-sync-contract.md` defines the local file-backed realtime boundary while issue capacity is blocked | Needs workspace capacity/config rollout |
 | Observability for self-use | Local readiness gate, traces, status snapshots, HUD/status contract, risk ledger, progress-sync contract | `npm run observability:ready` reports 21/21 | Complete for local gate |
@@ -501,9 +507,9 @@ repo evidence and merge commits.
 | Queue hygiene and salvage | GitHub PR/issue state, salvage ledger | Append ledger entries for any future stale closures | Every cleanup batch |
 | Release and publication | rc.1 release docs, publication readiness doc | Naming matrix and plugin submission/contact checklist | Before any tag |
 | Harness OS core | Audit, adapter matrix, observability docs, `ecc2/` | HUD/session-control acceptance spec | Weekly until GA |
-| Evaluation and RAG | Reference-set validation, harness audit, traces, ECC-Tools corpus | Read-only evaluator/RAG prototype plus stale-salvage, billing-readiness, CI-failure-diagnosis, harness-config-quality, AgentShield policy-exception, skill-quality evidence, deep-analyzer evidence, and RAG/evaluator comparison fixtures; ECC-Tools #68 publishes the corpus as a hosted promotion readiness check-run, #69 scores cached hosted job outputs against the same corpus, #70 emits ranked retrieval candidates plus a model prompt seed, and #71 adds a fail-closed hosted model-judge request contract | Live hosted model-judge execution behind fixture gates |
+| Evaluation and RAG | Reference-set validation, harness audit, traces, ECC-Tools corpus | Read-only evaluator/RAG prototype plus stale-salvage, billing-readiness, CI-failure-diagnosis, harness-config-quality, AgentShield policy-exception, skill-quality evidence, deep-analyzer evidence, and RAG/evaluator comparison fixtures; ECC-Tools #68 publishes the corpus as a hosted promotion readiness check-run, #69 scores cached hosted job outputs against the same corpus, #70 emits ranked retrieval candidates plus a model prompt seed, #71 adds a fail-closed hosted model-judge request contract, and #72 executes that judge only when explicitly enabled and backed by hosted retrieval citations | Hosted promotion telemetry and operator review UX |
 | AgentShield enterprise | AgentShield PR evidence and roadmap notes | Remediation workflow depth or corpus expansion follow-up | Next implementation batch |
-| ECC Tools app | ECC-Tools PR evidence, billing audit, risk taxonomy, evaluator/RAG corpus | ECC-Tools #53 published the supply-chain workflow hardening branch, #54 tracks copy-ready PR drafts in the Linear/project backlog, #55 classifies analysis-depth readiness, #56 exposes the hosted execution plan, #57 executes the first hosted CI diagnostics job, #58 executes the hosted security evidence review job, #59 executes the hosted harness compatibility audit, #60 executes the hosted reference-set evaluation, #61 executes the hosted AI routing/cost review, #62 executes hosted team backlog routing, #63 publishes the hosted depth-plan check-run, #64 dispatches hosted jobs from PR comments, #65 persists hosted result history/check-runs, #66 exposes hosted job status from PR comments, #67 makes depth-plan recommendations cache-aware, #68 publishes hosted promotion readiness from the evaluator/RAG corpus, #69 scores cached hosted job outputs against that corpus, #70 emits ranked retrieval candidates plus a model prompt seed, and #71 emits the gated `hosted-promotion-judge.v1` contract without live model calls; next work is live hosted model-judge execution | Next implementation batch |
+| ECC Tools app | ECC-Tools PR evidence, billing audit, risk taxonomy, evaluator/RAG corpus | ECC-Tools #53 published the supply-chain workflow hardening branch, #54 tracks copy-ready PR drafts in the Linear/project backlog, #55 classifies analysis-depth readiness, #56 exposes the hosted execution plan, #57 executes the first hosted CI diagnostics job, #58 executes the hosted security evidence review job, #59 executes the hosted harness compatibility audit, #60 executes the hosted reference-set evaluation, #61 executes the hosted AI routing/cost review, #62 executes hosted team backlog routing, #63 publishes the hosted depth-plan check-run, #64 dispatches hosted jobs from PR comments, #65 persists hosted result history/check-runs, #66 exposes hosted job status from PR comments, #67 makes depth-plan recommendations cache-aware, #68 publishes hosted promotion readiness from the evaluator/RAG corpus, #69 scores cached hosted job outputs against that corpus, #70 emits ranked retrieval candidates plus a model prompt seed, #71 emits the gated `hosted-promotion-judge.v1` contract without live model calls, and #72 adds opt-in live model-judge execution behind hosted-evidence and strict JSON/citation gates | Next implementation batch |
 | Linear progress | Linear project status updates, `docs/architecture/progress-sync-contract.md`, and this mirror | Status update with queue/evidence/missing gates | Every significant merge batch |
 
 The project status update should always include:
@@ -720,10 +726,9 @@ Acceptance:
    PR #82 expanded corpus coverage for env proxy hijacks and out-of-band
    exfiltration; and ECC-Tools PRs #42/#43 now route and recognize evidence
    packs. The next slice is hosted evidence-pack workflow depth.
-2. Implement live hosted model-judge execution on top of the #71
+2. Add hosted promotion telemetry and operator review UX on top of the #72
-   deterministic judge contract, keeping vector/model judgment behind fixture
+   gated model execution path so live judgments can be audited before any
-   evaluation, entitlement, budget, provider configuration, and non-blocking
+   promotion policy becomes enforceable.
-   check-run policy gates.
 3. Enable/configure the merged Linear backlog sync path after workspace issue
    capacity clears or the Linear workspace is upgraded, then verify PR-draft
    salvage items land in the expected project.

tests/docs/evaluator-rag-prototype.test.js

@@ -135,7 +135,7 @@ test('roadmap points to the evaluator RAG prototype and hosted PR check', () =>
 
   assert.ok(roadmap.includes('docs/architecture/evaluator-rag-prototype.md'));
   assert.ok(roadmap.includes('examples/evaluator-rag-prototype/'));
-  assert.ok(roadmap.includes('Deterministic hosted PR check, cached output scoring, retrieval planning, and judge contract integrated; live hosted model execution remains future'));
+  assert.ok(roadmap.includes('Deterministic hosted PR check, cached output scoring, retrieval planning, judge contract, and gated model execution integrated'));
 });
 
 test('billing readiness scenario rejects launch copy overclaims', () => {