Files
everything-claude-code/EVALUATION.md
2026-03-28 20:03:26 -04:00

123 lines
4.2 KiB
Markdown

# Repo Evaluation vs Current Setup
**Date:** 2026-03-21
**Branch:** `claude/evaluate-repo-comparison-ASZ9Y`
---
## Current Setup (`~/.claude/`)
The active Claude Code installation is near-minimal:
| Component | Current |
|-----------|---------|
| Agents | 0 |
| Skills | 0 installed |
| Commands | 0 |
| Hooks | 1 (Stop: git check) |
| Rules | 0 |
| MCP configs | 0 |
**Installed hooks:**
- `Stop``stop-hook-git-check.sh` — blocks session end if there are uncommitted changes or unpushed commits
**Installed permissions:**
- `Skill` — allows skill invocations
**Plugins:** Only `blocklist.json` (no active plugins installed)
---
## This Repo (`everything-claude-code` v1.9.0)
| Component | Repo |
|-----------|------|
| Agents | 28 |
| Skills | 116 |
| Commands | 59 |
| Rules sets | 12 languages + common (60+ rule files) |
| Hooks | Comprehensive system (PreToolUse, PostToolUse, SessionStart, Stop) |
| MCP configs | 1 (Context7 + others) |
| Schemas | 9 JSON validators |
| Scripts/CLI | 46+ Node.js modules + multiple CLIs |
| Tests | 58 test files |
| Install profiles | core, developer, security, research, full |
| Supported harnesses | Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, OpenCode |
---
## Gap Analysis
### Hooks
- **Current:** 1 Stop hook (git hygiene check)
- **Repo:** Full hook matrix covering:
- Dangerous command blocking (`rm -rf`, force pushes)
- Auto-formatting on file edits
- Dev server tmux enforcement
- Cost tracking
- Session evaluation and governance capture
- MCP health monitoring
### Agents (28 missing)
The repo provides specialized agents for every major workflow:
- Language reviewers: TypeScript, Python, Go, Java, Kotlin, Rust, C++, Flutter
- Build resolvers: Go, Java, Kotlin, Rust, C++, PyTorch
- Workflow agents: planner, tdd-guide, code-reviewer, security-reviewer, architect
- Automation: loop-operator, doc-updater, refactor-cleaner, harness-optimizer
### Skills (116 missing)
Domain knowledge modules covering:
- Language patterns (Python, Go, Kotlin, Rust, C++, Java, Swift, Perl, Laravel, Django)
- Testing strategies (TDD, E2E, coverage)
- Architecture patterns (backend, frontend, API design, database migrations)
- AI/ML workflows (Claude API, eval harness, agent loops, cost-aware pipelines)
- Business workflows (investor materials, market research, content engine)
### Commands (59 missing)
- `/tdd`, `/plan`, `/e2e`, `/code-review` — core dev workflows
- `/sessions`, `/save-session`, `/resume-session` — session persistence
- `/orchestrate`, `/multi-plan`, `/multi-execute` — multi-agent coordination
- `/learn`, `/skill-create`, `/evolve` — continuous improvement
- `/build-fix`, `/verify`, `/quality-gate` — build/quality automation
### Rules (60+ files missing)
Language-specific coding style, patterns, testing, and security guidelines for:
TypeScript, Python, Go, Java, Kotlin, Rust, C++, C#, Swift, Perl, PHP, and common/cross-language rules.
---
## Recommendations
### Immediate value (core install)
Run `ecc install --profile core` to get:
- Core agents (code-reviewer, planner, tdd-guide, security-reviewer)
- Essential skills (tdd-workflow, coding-standards, security-review)
- Key commands (/tdd, /plan, /code-review, /build-fix)
### Full install
Run `ecc install --profile full` to get all 28 agents, 116 skills, and 59 commands.
### Hooks upgrade
The current Stop hook is solid. The repo's `hooks.json` adds:
- Dangerous command blocking (safety)
- Auto-formatting (quality)
- Cost tracking (observability)
- Session evaluation (learning)
### Rules
Adding language rules (e.g., TypeScript, Python) provides always-on coding guidelines without relying on per-session prompts.
---
## What the Current Setup Does Well
- The `stop-hook-git-check.sh` Stop hook is production-quality and already enforces good git hygiene
- The `Skill` permission is correctly configured
- The setup is clean with no conflicts or cruft
---
## Summary
The current setup is essentially a blank slate with one well-implemented git hygiene hook. This repo provides a complete, production-tested enhancement layer covering agents, skills, commands, hooks, and rules — with a selective install system so you can add exactly what you need without bloating the configuration.